What we found
- Melbourne wins the inner city. Within five kilometres of the city, 99% can walk to a train or tram. Sydney has 88%.
- The gap is widest just past that. Five to ten kilometres out, it is 92% in Melbourne against 46% in Sydney.
- Sydney takes over further out. Twenty to thirty kilometres from the city, 40% of Sydneysiders can walk to one. Melbourne has 23%.
- Some big suburbs have none at all. Rowville, Melbourne, has almost 34,000 people and not one lives within a 15 minute walk.
Our research: How convenient is your suburb
The story: which city has better public transport, Sydney or Melbourne?
It depends on how far from the city you live. We counted who lives within a 15 minute walk of a train or tram. Within five kilometres of the city, it is 99% of people in Melbourne and 88% in Sydney. Five to ten kilometres out, Melbourne has 92% and Sydney 46%. Ten to fifteen out, Melbourne still leads, 68% to 54%.
Then the cities swap. Fifteen to twenty kilometres out, Sydney leads 58% to 41%. Twenty to thirty kilometres out, Sydney has 40% and Melbourne 23%. Across each whole city, the shares end up close, 48% in Melbourne and 45% in Sydney.
Where in Sydney can't you walk to a train?
Some of Sydney's gaps sit close to the city. Mosman, five and a half kilometres from the city, has about 28,000 people and none within a 15 minute walk. Dee Why, on the Northern Beaches, has about 23,000 and the nearest station is about 11 kilometres away.
Further out, the lines reach more people. In Westmead and Wentworthville, about 21 kilometres west of the city, almost everyone can walk to a station. Hornsby, in the north, has 89% within a 15 minute walk. Greystanes, Glenmore Park and Oran Park, in the west and south west, have none.
Where in Melbourne can't you walk to a train or tram?
Rowville, about 28 kilometres south east of the city, has almost 34,000 people. Not one lives within a 15 minute walk of a train or tram. On average the nearest station is about five and a half kilometres away. Doncaster East, Endeavour Hills, Caroline Springs and Wollert, each with more than 24,000 people, are the same.
Where a line does run, the outer suburbs do well. Noble Park, 25 kilometres south east, has 80% within a 15 minute walk. Mitcham, in the east, has 79%.
Does Melbourne have more cafes and bars than Sydney?
Yes, close to the city. Within ten kilometres of the city, we counted about 2,100 cafes, bars and pubs in Melbourne and about 1,800 in Sydney. Melbourne is ahead in both rings. Within five kilometres it has about 1,400 against Sydney's 1,200, and from five to ten kilometres out about 700 against 600.
The busiest strips show it best. Fitzroy, two kilometres north east of the Melbourne city centre, has about 210 within a kilometre of its busiest corner. Redfern, Sydney's best outside the city, has about 135. Brunswick and South Melbourne have about 95 each and Richmond about 80. In Sydney, Newtown has about 85, and Bondi Beach and Parramatta about 70 each.
How we made this reel
- We took every block of homes in both cities. About 4.7 million people in Sydney and 4.3 million in Melbourne, from the 2021 Census.
- Then we measured to the nearest train or tram stop. A 15 minute walk is 1.2 kilometres in a straight line. Metro and light rail count.
- And grouped people by distance from the city. Rings five kilometres wide near the centre, then ten, out to about 55 kilometres.
What it means for you
- Check the walk before you inspect. A suburb near a line can still leave whole streets out of walking range.
- Look past the suburb name. Inside one suburb, some streets are a short walk from a station and others are not.
- Compare like with like. Outer Sydney often beats outer Melbourne on rail, while inner Melbourne beats inner Sydney.
Where to see it on Microburbs
- Convenience, in every suburb report. Each microburb is scored on the walk to transport, shops and schools.
- The liveability map, street by street. It colours every microburb in the suburb, so you can see which streets are close.
See the walk to the train in Rowville →
Get the data
The walk to transport is scored for every microburb in Australia, live in our data service. St Kilda (Vic.), Melbourne comes back with 315 microburbs, each scored on seven things. On convenience, which counts the walk to transport, 313 of the 315 score 80 or more out of 100.
Try it now, free. This request is free for our sample suburbs, one in each state and territory, with no sign up and no card:
curl "https://api.microburbs.com.au/v1/suburbs/St%20Kilda%20%28Vic.%29/lifestyle/livability-map" \
-H "Authorization: Bearer test"
What it sent back on 15 November 2026, cut to one microburb:
{
"data": {
"suburb": "St Kilda (Vic.)",
"metric": "livability_scores",
"unit": "score_0_100",
"n_microburbs": 315,
"microburbs": [
{
"mb": "20520240000",
"street": "Shakespeare",
"scores": {
"affluence": 79,
"lifestyle": 98,
"hip": 97,
"convenience": 98,
"family": 2,
"safety": 38,
"tranquility": 4
},
"levels": {
"affluence": "High",
"lifestyle": "Very high",
"hip": "Very high",
"convenience": "Very high",
"family": "Very low",
"safety": "Low",
"tranquility": "Very low"
}
}
]
}
}
See the full API docs for every request, the price of each and how to get a key for the rest of Australia.
How close is my suburb to a train station?
Convenience, in every suburb report. Each microburb is scored on the walk to transport, shops and schools.
More reels
Walter Burley Griffin and Castlecrag: the Sydney suburb built by Canberra's designer
Weird streets in Australia: the history behind odd suburb layouts
When was Australia explored? The main European voyages and expeditions, 1606 to 1939
Who lives in Werribee? Young families on the new estates, older singles near the centre